The Ice Man and the Wasp Factory triumph at Carton House

Maynooth University Senior Cup team (from left) Stephen Kinch, Jack Walsh, Kyle McCarron, Donal Scott (coach), Declan Loftus, Ronan Mullarney and Jake Whelan after their victory in the AIG Senior Cup Final at Carton House Golf Club. Picture by Pat Cashman

Maynooth University captured the AIG Senior Cup for the first time in the club’s history when Jake Whelan bravely holed a nine-foot putt on the 18th to give them a 3-2 win over Ulster champions Knock at Carton House.

The 20-year old, playing in his first match of the campaign for the students, got up and down from greenside sand for a closing par four on the O’Meara Course to beat Mark McMurray by one hole having duffed a wedge to lose the 17th to a par and send the match down the last.

In the AIG Jimmy Bruen Shield final, Munster champions Ballybunion enjoyed a 3.5 - 1.5 win over Castlebar, securing the title for the second time following their win in the second edition of the competition 36 years ago.

Ballybunion celebrate on the 15th green victory in the AIG Jimmy Bruen Shield Final at Carton House Golf Club today (19/09/2015). Picture by Pat Cashman

Ballybunion drew on their mix of youth and experience to capture the Jimmy Bruen Shield for the first time since 1979 and guarantee that an All Ireland title headed back to the Kingdom before a ball was kicked in anger at Croke Park.

His All Ireland tickets safely tucked away in his back pocket, team captain Pat O’Sullivan made several personnel changes in the line up for Saturday’s final with Castlebar and walked way a winner as the Kerry club triumphed by 3.5 to 1.5 over the O’Meara Course at Carton House.

With a 20-strong squad ranging in age from 15 to 60, it was Adrian Walsh and Brian Slattery who delivered the winning point with a 4 and 3 win over Michael Kilcourse and Shane Rice in the anchor match.

Brian Slattery and Adrian Walsh (Ballybunion) celebrates winning their match and the AIG Jimmy Bruen Shield Final on the 15th green at Carton House. Picture by Pat Cashman

“They were one down after three but they fought back,” smiled O’Sullivan. “They don’t like to be riled and once you tickle a nest of wasps you know what’s going to happen. And it happened.”

New pairing James Lavery and Paul Enright lost 5 and 4 in the top match but Ronan Cross and Finbarr Carrig beat John McHugh and Gary Corbett 4 and 2 to level the score before Mark Dilger was handed a new partner in 16 year old Iarla O’Mahony and they emerged with a 5 and 4 win.

Another new pairing in Padraig Quill and John Eggleston were four down at one stage but as they battled back against Ryan O’Malley and Mark Jennings and looked likely to square their match on 16, Walsh hit a fine third to 10 feet at the par-five 15th and Slattery lagged the birdie putt dead to secure the crucial third point and the title for Ballybunion.

Ronan Cross (Ballybunion) is congratulated by Paul Enright after victory on the 16th green the AIG Jimmy Bruen Shield Final. Picture by Pat Cashman

“Ronan Cross is only 15 but he plays like a 25 year old with the wisdom of a man of 65,” O’Sullivan said of his troops. “And the bottom match of Adrian Walsh and Brian Slattery could play Ryder Cup.”

The captain paid tribute to all his squad and those who played key roles in  tight matches in West Munster as well as the Area and Munster finals.

But he also did his homework, taking on local caddies who knew the greens well.

“It was a really strong team performance and a club effort,” O’Sullivan said. “We made friends here which is what it is all about. And they represented the club with great dignity and integrity as did Castlebar today and Fortwilliam in the semi-finals.”

Ballybunion, winners of the 2015 AIG Jimmy Bruen Shield. Picture by Pat Cashman

As Ballybunion celebrated, Maynooth University were forced to dig deeper than they imagined to clinch the college’s first AIG Senior Cup title with a 3-2 win over Ulster champions Knock.

And it was former Leinster Boys Interprovincial Jake Whelan went from forgotten man to “Ice Man” as he bravely holed a nine-foot par putt on the final green to give the college the first of what could be many wins in the blue riband championship.

The students looked to be heading for a comfortable win when Ronan Mullarney beat Michael Sinclair 3 and 2 at No 1 and anchor man Jack Walsh, who’d holed a five-iron on the fly from 178 yards at the eighth for an eagle two and chipped for birdie at the 12th, saw off Simon Miskelly 4 and 3.

"I just drew it in a bit and it went straight in," Walsh, a Senior Cup winner with Castle in 2012, said of his eagle. "It took half the hole with it. He had missed the green just right. That got me two up and  to chip on 12 to go three up was huge." 

Knock had just one win on the board — a 6 and 5 procession for South of Ireland runner up and international Colin Fairweather, who was six under par as he stunned Donegal man Kyle McCarron.

Jake Whelan (Maynooth) holes the winning putt on the 18th green in the AIG Senior Cup Final at Carton House Golf Club. Picture by Pat Cashman

But when Knock’s James Patterson holed an unlikely 45 footer down the 18th green to beat Stephen Kinch by one hole and tie the scores at 2-2, Whelan’s match became the decider.

The 20-year old was two up at the turn but as he made his first start in the competition, he admitted that nerves began to kick in as he headed down the stretch against the experienced Mark McMurray.

He wobbled a few times, losing the 15th after carving his tee shot into the hazard and then found himself being forced to hole a 12 footer for par at the 16th, where he blocked a six-iron, to remain one up after watching his opponent lip out from 25 feet for birdie there.

He looked likely take a lead to the 18th or even close out the match on the par-five 17th, when McMurray bunkered his lay up and then left himself close to 60 feet for birdie.

But Whelan inexplicably duffed his 100 yard third and took six to lose the hole and send the game, and the AIG Senior Cup, to the 18th.

AIG Senior Cup winners Maynooth University. Picture by Pat Cashman

“I hit the worst wedge shot I have ever hit and ended up losing the 17th out of nowhere,” said a relieved and delighted Whelan at the finish, where he hit a great drive and then a good greenside bunker shot to nine feet before holing the par putt after McMurray had driven behind the chestnut tree on the left and taken five.

“But I forgot about it as soon as I could and made sure I committed to the drive on 18. It feels great to get a match — and win.”

Walker Cup hero Gary Hurley turned up straight from a successful appearance at the First Stage of Q-School in Scotland to support his old college team mates.

“Well done, ‘Ice Man’,” Hurley said, giving Whelan his new nickname.

That Mullarney was the only first choice player remaining from the side that won the Leinster title — most of the rest, including internationals Stuart Grehan and Robin Dawson were in action in the European Universities Championship in Switzerland — has generated debate over the wisdom of allowing a scholarship based golf programme to compete in inter-club competition.

“The rules are what they are, we just put a team together and compete as best we can,” said stand in manager Donal Scott, who is one of four coaches the university uses for its golf programme alongside Johnny Foster, Kenny Fahy and Noel Fox.

As for "Ice Man" Whelan, Scott said: "A man of few words but a great talent. It was his first game. It certainly made us a bit nervy when Stephen lost on 18. 

Gary Hurley watching the AIG Senior Cup Final at Carton House Golf Club. Picture by Pat Cashman

"And while Jake was one up playing 17, to lose that and come back as strong as he did with a super drive and then show nerves of steel to roll in that nine footer, that was exceptional. I am thrilled for him.

"He is a great guy and I couldn’t be prouder of him the way he held it together on the last hole."

AIG Cups and Shields, National Finals, Carton House (O’Meara Course)

AIG Senior Cup final

Maynooth University 3, Knock 2 (Maynooth University names first)

  1. Ronan Mullarney bt Michael Sinclair 3/2;
  2. Kyle McCarron lost to Colin Fairweather 6/5;
  3. Stephen Kinch lost to James Patterson 1 hole;
  4. Jake Whelan bt Mark McMurray 1 hole;
  5. Jack Walsh bt Simon Miskelly Knock 4/3.

AIG Jimmy Bruen Shield final

Ballybunion 3.5, Castlebar 1.5 (Ballybunion names first)

  1. James Lavery & Paul Enright lost to Tom Moylett & Ian Brennan 5/4;

  2. Ronan Cross & Finbarr Carrig bt John McHugh & Gary Corbett 4/2;
  3. Mark Dilger & Iarla O’Mahony bt Paddy Burke & Dave Walsh 5/4;
  4. Padraig Quill & John Eggleston halved with Ryan O’Malley & Mark Jennings;
  5. Adrian Walsh & Brian Slattery bt Michael Kilcourse & Shane Rice 4/3.